Montgomery County agrees to $1 million lawsuit settlement over jail food allegations

Montgomery County agrees to $1 million lawsuit settlement over jail meals allegations

Frito-Lay Sweet & Salty Snacks Variety Box, Mix of Cookies, Crackers, Chips & Nuts, 50 Count
  • 50 count of Frito Lay snacks for the office
  • The Frito lay sweet and salty snack box provides a quick and...

MONTGOMERY COUNTY — Legal professionals representing 2,300 former inmates of the County Jail have agreed to settle a category motion lawsuit towards the county for $1 million. 

The settlement was filed Wednesday in the U.S. District Courtroom for the Northern District of New York by legal professional E. Robert Keach of Amsterdam, who represents the unique “class representatives” for the lawsuit, former jail inmates Perry Hill and James Rogers. The lawsuit alleged that inmates have been disadvantaged of enough meals.

The settlement should now be permitted by U.S. District Courtroom Choose Brenda Ok. Sannes.

Keach mentioned he’ll file a movement on Friday asking Sannes to approve the settlement. He mentioned he anticipates Sannes will rule on the settlement quickly. 


Our subscribers assist us carry this info to you. Please contemplate a subscription at Already a subscriber? Thanks!

“The events reached a settlement that everybody concerned agrees is honest,” he mentioned. “My colleagues and I are pleased with the job that we did representing the category on this case, and we’re completely satisfied we obtained a decision to the advantage of our class members. We’re additionally completely satisfied that each Sheriff Jeff Smith and County Legal professional [Meghan] Manion have instituted a variety of optimistic adjustments on the jail following [former Sheriff] Michael Amato’s departure from county authorities.”  

The lawsuit alleged that inmates weren’t offered enough vitamin in violation of the eighth and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Structure throughout their time in custody. The jail was overseen by Amato at the moment. 

Hill was the primary one to file the lawsuit in 2014, alleging he was solely fed 1,700 energy per day, and generally much less, when he was held on the jail from October 2013 to March 2014 on a parole violation.

The swimsuit argued grownup males want 2,400 to three,000 energy per day, relying on bodily exertion.
In his testimony for the case, Amato claimed he was conscious the inmates complained they wished extra meals and have been hungry, however believed the complaints have been made as a result of they wished the commissary again, which had been taken away.

One inmate, Andre Cruz, mentioned in his testimony inmates have been relegated to consuming oral hygiene merchandise whereas on the jail.

“The final meal was at perhaps quarter to five p.m. We don’t eat once more till the subsequent day round 7 p.m.” he mentioned in his testimony. “So, we ate toothpaste, we ordered Halls from commissary, earlier than they took that away, simply to type of not starve.” 

Montgomery County Government Matt Ossenfort supplied an announcement in regards to the settlement Thursday:  
“This was the primary lawsuit that got here throughout my desk in 2014 once I first started my time period as county govt. I’m happy that after years of working to succeed in an settlement that’s mutual to all events, we have now performed that,” Ossenfort mentioned. “I am much more happy that we will put this challenge behind us.” 

As a part of the settlement, Montgomery County continues to disclaim any wrongdoing within the case.

“I might say, we’re at all times striving to enhance and turn into higher, and I believe there was lots of positives and enhancements on the public security facility in Montgomery County,” Ossenfort mentioned. 

The settlement splits $622,500 amongst inmates who qualify for compensation; and about 30 %, $300,000, goes to legal professional charges. It additionally units apart $50,000 for a third-party administrator to offer discover to all the potential members of the lawsuit.


Our subscribers assist us carry this info to you. Please contemplate a subscription at Already a subscriber? Thanks!

To be eligible for any a part of the settlement a former jail inmate must have been incarcerated for a minimum of 14 consecutive days between July 25, 2011 to Dec. 31, 2018.

Hill and Rodgers every obtain an “incentive award” of $10,000 every for his or her willingness to
step ahead and file the swimsuit, along with their share of the general settlement. 

An inmate’s share of the settlement can be decided by two elements: what number of eligible inmates put in claims for the settlement and what number of days these inmates spent within the jail. Extra days equals a larger share as much as a cap of 365 days. 

Witnesses within the lawsuit additionally have been awarded $500 along with their share of the settlement. 

Each eligible inmate that submits a declare to settlement will obtain at the least $50 along with their share of the general settlement. 

After notices are distributed to potential members of the lawsuit, inmates have 60 days to decide out of the settlement, preserving their proper to file their very own lawsuit. If they do not decide out, they waive that proper.